Skip to Content
Streetsblog Empire State home
Streetsblog Empire State home
Log In
Automated Enforcement

DATA: Not Paying Fines? Keep Speeding, Says New York City

12:03 AM EDT on September 30, 2025

    Another day, another way to look at drivers dodging accountability.

    The more speeding tickets a driver collects, the fewer he pays, according to city ticketing statistics crunched by data journalist Michael Cahana.

    Cahana combed through city data and found that drivers with violations such as going through red lights or speeding through school zones, simply stop paying most of their tickets once they start accruing more of them, because they operate in what Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch would call a "consequence-free environment" (a term she invented to describe cyclists, however).

    People with just a handful of violations usually pay them off, but such compliance drops off, with some scofflaws paying as few as one in seven tickets once they get more than 80 fines, the researcher and reporter found.

    Worse: after a driver is "in judgment" for more than $350 in unpaid fines – about five school-zone tickets – his car can be towed or booted ... but very few are..

    Cahana found that half of the motorists in judgment continued committing violations – something that would not happen if their cars were towed, as they could be if the city better connected the dots between the army of NYPD traffic agents handing out tickets and its towing operations, a shortcoming that Streetsblog has documented.

    See the data for yourself (scroll through because the graphic is delightfully interactive):

    This status quo leads to staggering numbers of drivers entering judgment every day, yet they continue to speed, as Cahana's data visualization shows.

    Not only does that cost the city millions of dollars in lost revenue, more importantly, this allows tens of thousands of school zone violations to go unpunished, creating a culture of "anything goes," as soon-to-be-former Mayor Adams likes to say.

    Stay in touch

    Sign up for our free newsletter

    More from Streetsblog Empire State

    Friday Headlines: Bus Pilot Redux Edition

    An outgoing lawmaker has big plans for buses. And more news.

    March 13, 2026

    Hired Actors, Paid Media: Big Tech Has Already Dumped $8M Into Hochul’s Car Insurance Ploy

    Buckets of cash and ads with professional actors are boosting Uber and Hochul's cause.

    March 13, 2026

    New MTA Accessibility Advisory Panel Guidelines Bar Members from ADA Lawsuits

    Disability justice advocates the Advisory Committee for Transit Accessibility accused the MTA of marginalizing the panel, which ex-transit boss Andy Byford created in 2019.

    March 13, 2026

    MTA Demands Albany Deal With Toll Evasion Already

    A new analysis of toll evasion found that the amount of money owed by drivers who don't pay paper toll invoices has more than doubled since 2022, from $147 million in unpaid tolls to nearly $350 million.

    March 12, 2026

    Hochul’s Car Insurance Plan Blows Fraud Way Out Of Proportion: Stats

    Gov. Hochul's proposal to lower car insurance premiums is built on suspected fraud. But a body of evidence reveals that there really is very little.

    Thursday Headlines: Train Meets Canal Edition

    Upstate New York needs high speed rail. And more news.

    March 12, 2026
    See all posts