Skip to Content
Streetsblog Empire State home
Streetsblog Empire State home
Log In
Automated Enforcement

HEAR IT! Staten Island Pol Loves to Speed — Then Shrugs Off His Recklessness

3:18 PM EDT on June 26, 2025

    David Carr — speed demon.

    Whaddya gonna do?

    Staten Island Council Member David Carr shrugged and drove away from a Streetsblog reporter who confronted him on Thursday about his long record of reckless driving: 12 speed-camera tickets, one red light ticket and one bus lane infraction since Feb. 2, 2023.

    Streetsblog spotted the slack-jawed Mid-Island Republican getting into his car in the City Hall parking lot at around noon and quickly ran his plates through the city database to confirm that his car has been piloted in a consistently reckless fashion — though, of course, the lawmaker may not be the sole driver.

    We ran over to ask about it, and Carr's indifferent shrug was so striking that it could practically be heard on tape:

    Here's the transcript:

    City records show that all of Carr's $1,000-plus in tickets have been paid. Left unknown, however, is why he is endangering his neighbors by driving at least 11 miles per hour above the speed limit in his mostly residential district.

    He drove off without comment.

    Carr isn't the first Rock Republican to be caught on camera driving recklessly. Former South Shore Council Member Joe Borelli was a famous member of the "Speed Demon Club," both here and overseas. He also shrugged off concerns about exceeding the speed limit.

    But speeding is a cause of considerable carnage in the city — and in Carr's 50th Council District. Last year in the Mid-Island district, 1,112 people were injured in 2,048 reported crashes, including 45 cyclists and 140 pedestrians, according to city statistics.

    Stay in touch

    Sign up for our free newsletter

    More from Streetsblog Empire State

    Monday Headlines: Surprising Overlap Edition

    Car insurance and robotaxis form a potent Albany stew, and more news.

    March 9, 2026

    Friday Headlines: Wrong Island Edition

    Nassau County is coming for your e-bikes. And more news.

    March 6, 2026

    Thursday Headlines: Insurance Who Insurance Why Edition

    Auto insurance proposals ain't adding up. Plus other news.

    March 5, 2026

    ‘Stupendous Potential’: Pay-Per-Mile Auto Insurance Would Cut Costs And Traffic Violence

    Lowering car insurance costs doesn't have to eviscerate crash victims' rights.

    March 5, 2026

    Study: AVs Will Super-Charge VMT

    Some look at autonomous vehicles as the future of travel in New York, but their effect on car dependency is straight from the past.

    March 5, 2026

    State Senate Majority Leader Wants Answers on Insurance

    The growing chorus of state lawmakers who want clarity on how the governor's auto insurance proposal helps real New Yorkers now includes Stewart-Cousins, the second-most-powerful woman in state government.

    March 4, 2026
    See all posts