Skip to Content
Streetsblog Empire State home
Streetsblog Empire State home
Log In
Auto Insurance

Heastie Undecided On Gov. Hochul’s Uber-Backed Push to Lower Car Insurance Rates

The Assembly Speaker is definitely not sold on Gov. Hochul's effort to reduce car insurance costs by lowing payouts to victims.

5:08 PM EST on January 21, 2026

    You can be insurance is going to be a big deal in the 2026 state budget.

    |Austin C. Jefferson

    ALBANY — The most powerful man in the state legislature said he's not yet sold on Gov. Hochul's bid to reduce auto insurance costs for drivers because it is likely to be achieved by lowering the compensation paid out to victims of road violence.

    Assembly Speaker Carl Heastie (D-Bronx) said on Wednesday that the governor's Uber-backed proposal — which advocates and legal professionals have already panned as an unconscionable attempt to shift the cost of insurance onto crash victims — is certainly not dead on arrival, but also certainly needs extensive debate.

    "I do agree that insurance rates are very high, but we have to figure this out, because I do think victims of accidents [sic] need to have their settlements and their days in court," he told reporters. "And maybe we'll find something that works for everybody. The government is trying to deal with a problem, but I also know that we don't want to leave victims of accidents [sic] without being compensated."

    It's the first comments to the press corps from top Albany leadership since the governor made the proposal in her State of the State address. State Senate Majority Leader Andrea Stewart-Cousins said on NY1's Inside City Hall last week only that her chamber would "take a look and see what the governor is proposing and see what we can actually do that could be helpful in this affordability crisis."

    Hochul believes that auto insurance premiums are too high in New York State in part because the definition of "serious injury" is too vague and is resulting in sky-high payouts. Currently, the term covers death, dismemberment, significant disfigurement, a fracture, loss of a fetus, loss or significant limitation of a body function or organ, or a non-permanent injury which prevents a person from daily activities for more than 90 days after the crash.

    In reality, these payouts already require a fair amount of verification before a settlement can be rendered.

    Both Heastie and Hochul have pinpointed the car-driver cost-reduction agenda as one of the more contentious issues that lie ahead during the state budget's negotiations.

    "I think [it's] going to probably be, if you ask me, the policy thing that'll have the most conversation," said Heastie. "[From] my, like, 800-foot view of the governor's executive budget."

    Stay in touch

    Sign up for our free newsletter

    More from Streetsblog Empire State

    Friday Headlines: Bus Pilot Redux Edition

    An outgoing lawmaker has big plans for buses. And more news.

    March 13, 2026

    Hired Actors, Paid Media: Big Tech Has Already Dumped $8M Into Hochul’s Car Insurance Ploy

    Buckets of cash and ads with professional actors are boosting Uber and Hochul's cause.

    March 13, 2026

    New MTA Accessibility Advisory Panel Guidelines Bar Members from ADA Lawsuits

    Disability justice advocates the Advisory Committee for Transit Accessibility accused the MTA of marginalizing the panel, which ex-transit boss Andy Byford created in 2019.

    March 13, 2026

    MTA Demands Albany Deal With Toll Evasion Already

    A new analysis of toll evasion found that the amount of money owed by drivers who don't pay paper toll invoices has more than doubled since 2022, from $147 million in unpaid tolls to nearly $350 million.

    March 12, 2026

    Hochul’s Car Insurance Plan Blows Fraud Way Out Of Proportion: Stats

    Gov. Hochul's proposal to lower car insurance premiums is built on suspected fraud. But a body of evidence reveals that there really is very little.

    Thursday Headlines: Train Meets Canal Edition

    Upstate New York needs high speed rail. And more news.

    March 12, 2026
    See all posts